Book a demo

Claim Check

Your supplier wants 8% more. How much of it can be justified?

Claim Check sets every argument in the price letter against the market index, comparable suppliers, previous increases, your contract and the exchange rate. You see which percentage is defensible and get a counter-proposal with a draft reply.

Book a demo Or test one claim for free ↓
Claim Check · CC-2606-031 Example analysis · fictional supplier and illustrative figures

Fictional Steel BV · hot-rolled plate S235

Price letter 2 Jun 2026 · effective 1 Jul 2026 · volume €1.2m/year · contract NL-2024-0118

Largely unjustified
Supplier asks
+8,0%
Justified
+1,4%
Counter-proposal
+1,5%
Scenario: annual difference
€78.000
(8.0% − 1.5%) × €1.2m annual spend
Supplier argumentWhat the data showsEffectVerdict
Raw material costs have risenHRC steel North-West Europe fell 3.1% since the March quote. § 4.2 of the contract already indexes quarterly on this series.0,0%No separate increase justified
Energy costs are much higherTTF gas rose 6% over the same period. Energy is about 8% of the cost price of hot-rolled plate.+0,5%Partly
Labour costs rise from 1 JuneA 4.5% wage increase is confirmed. Labour is about 20% of the cost price.+0,9%Justified
Transport has become more expensiveDiesel fell 4% since March. No freight calculation was provided.0,0%Not justified
Comparable suppliersTwo alternative suppliers quoted +1.5% and +2.0% in June for the same specification.
HistoryThe previous 6% increase (October 2025) was not corrected when HRC fell afterwards.
CurrencyPriced in euros. No currency effect.
Calculation
Energy8% × 6%0,5%
Labour costs20% × 4,5%0,9%
Raw materialindex falling0,0%
Transportnot demonstrated0,0%
Justified total1,4%

Cost price shares are assumptions for this category and can be adjusted.

Draft reply

Dear Jan,

Thank you for your price letter of 2 June. We cannot follow the requested 8%. The steel index on which § 4.2 of our agreement is based has fallen 3.1% since March.

For energy and labour costs we recognise a combined effect of about 1.4%. We therefore propose 1.5% from 1 July. For a higher percentage we would welcome a cost price breakdown, including the energy and freight calculation.

What Claim Check sets against the claim.

A supplier cites cost increases. The question is how much of that belongs in your price.

Market index

Does the increase follow the market series the cost price rests on, measured from the previous price adjustment?

HRC steel NWE · −3.1% since 12 Mar

Comparable suppliers

What do other suppliers ask for the same category in the same period?

2 quotes in June · +1.5% and +2.0%

History

Was a previous increase reversed when the market fell again?

Oct 2025 · +6% · not corrected

Contract position

What does your contract say about indexation, reference dates and termination? A claim outside the indexation clause needs extra justification.

§ 4.2 quarterly indexation · § 9.3 notice 3 months

Currency

How much of the movement comes from the exchange rate rather than higher costs?

EUR/USD +2.4% since quote

What you provide.

Your supplier’s price letter, email or quote. With volume and contract the verdict gets sharper; without them it still works.

Also works for quote claims, raw material claims, transport and logistics, delivery claims, contractual claims, indexation claims, geopolitical claims, capacity claims, NCR, quality and engineering, ESG and compliance, and currency and FX.

What you get back.

Verdict per argument

Refuted, partly, justified or evidence needed, with the source.

Justified percentage

Built up per argument, so you see where the difference lies.

Counter-proposal and draft reply

A percentage to take into the meeting and an email you can edit.

Questions for the meeting

Which cost price data to request before you accept anything.

Test one claim for free.

The same Claim Check as in Orbecta. You receive the briefing as a PDF within 5 to 15 minutes.

You first confirm your business email address. One trial scan per address per month.

How Claim Check reaches a verdict.

More in the Trust Center →

Sources

Every finding names the market series or source and the date. You can check every figure yourself.

Calculation

The justified percentage is built up per argument. The assumptions about cost price shares are in the briefing.

You decide

Counter-proposal and reply are drafts. Nothing goes to your supplier unless you send it.

Your document in the free test

After the scan and sending the briefing, we delete your document and the result. One trial scan per business email address per month.

Is there a price letter on your desk?

Bring it to the demo. We test it together and show what the reply to your supplier looks like.

Book a demo