Book a demo

Solution · Compare quotes and justify your choice

Which quote best fits your requirements and budget?

Compare quotes on total cost, lead time, quality and price risk. Record which differences decide your choice.

Book a demo
Award justification · RFQ-2026-044 Example · fictional suppliers and illustrative figures

Sheet metal framework agreement 2027

Laser cutting and bending · approx. €420,000/year · 3 quotes · weighting fixed 9 Sep 2026

Advice: quote C At the current steel price, C costs €15,000 a year more than B. B links its price to the steel index: with a rise of about 8%, C works out cheaper in this scenario. Even at an unchanged steel price, C delivers in 2 weeks instead of 5, with 90 ppm rejects against 450 at B.
CriterionWeightA · Fictional MetaalB · Sample SheetworksC · Example Plaattechniek
Total cost45%€452.0006€416.00010€431.0008
Price risk15%Fixed 12 months9Follows steel index quarterly4Fixed 12 months9
Lead time20%3 weeks75 weeks52 weeks9
Quality last year20%120 ppm8450 ppm490 ppm9
Weighted score 7,056,908,55
Rationale

C is €15,000 a year more expensive than B, but is priced fixed for twelve months, delivers in two weeks and had 90 ppm rejects last year, against 450 at B.

B’s price follows the steel index. If steel rises 10%, B is already €2,900 more expensive than C.

Within the 2027 budget of €440,000. For approval by the procurement manager.

Sensitivity · steel price
SteelCost BCost CBest option
−10%€398.100€431.000B
0%€416.000€431.000B
+10%€433.900€431.000C
+20%€451.800€431.000C

Assumption: material is 45% of B’s price. From about +8% steel, C is cheaper.

What a defensible choice needs.

An Excel sheet with three columns shows what’s cheaper. A justification shows why you choose something else.

Weighting fixed in advance

Criteria and weights are fixed before the quotes come in. That makes the decision defensible, also afterwards.

Fixed 9 Sep · quotes opened 30 Sep

Total cost, not the unit price

Orbecta includes transport, surcharges and payment terms, so quotes with a different structure become comparable.

B: €398,000 + €18,000 transport

Risk in euros

An indexed price is cheaper until the index rises. The sensitivity shows from which point a different choice works out better.

From approx. +8% steel, B costs more than C

Source for every figure

Prices from the quotes, quality figures from your own incoming inspection, market series with date.

PPM from incoming inspection 2026

One justification for everyone looking on.

Your manager

Whether the decision fits the budget and what it costs compared with the cheapest alternative.

Engineering and quality

Whether the chosen supplier meets drawing and quality requirements, with last year’s figures.

Finance

Total cost, payment terms and price risk over the term.

Audit

That the weighting was fixed in advance and that every figure is traceable.

What you use for this in Orbecta.

RFQ and quote comparison →

Puts quotes side by side and next to the market.

Supplier risks →

Shows what’s happening at the suppliers you’re comparing.

Contract monitoring →

Tracks after award whether agreements are kept.

Do you soon need to justify an award?

Bring the quotes to the demo. We’ll build the comparison and the justification together.

Book a demo